Italian giallo films and American thrillers share elements of suspense and crime, but their distinct approaches set them apart in style, structure, and atmosphere.

Visual Style and Atmosphere

Italian giallos are famous for their striking visuals—vivid colors, dramatic lighting, and surreal imagery. Directors like Dario Argento and Mario Bava use these elements to create a dreamlike, often unsettling atmosphere. American thrillers, on the other hand, focus more on realism, with a darker, grittier style that prioritizes narrative over visual flourish. Directors like Alfred Hitchcock emphasize psychological tension rather than surreal visuals.

Narrative Complexity

Giallos often have convoluted plots, where the focus is less on logic and more on mood and mystery. Twists and surprises abound, often leaving viewers disoriented. In contrast, American thrillers usually feature more structured, linear storytelling, with a clear focus on solving a crime or uncovering a hidden truth. They lean heavily on psychological tension, as seen in films like Se7en or Silence of the Lambs.

Violence and Eroticism

One of the hallmarks of giallo films is the stylized and graphic depiction of violence, often paired with erotic undertones. Murders are elaborately staged, almost becoming a visual spectacle. American thrillers, while often violent, usually depict it in a more restrained manner, serving the plot rather than becoming an artistic centerpiece. Eroticism, while present, is typically less pronounced and more separate from the core mystery.

Psychological vs. Surreal

American thrillers frequently explore the psychological makeup of their characters, focusing on the mental games between the protagonist and antagonist. Giallos, however, lean into surrealism, using disorienting visuals and bizarre motives to create a sense of unease, making the experience more emotional and symbolic.

Conclusion

While both genres offer suspense and intrigue, Italian giallos emphasize style, atmosphere, and visual storytelling, often pushing the boundaries of logic and narrative clarity. American thrillers, in contrast, are more grounded, focusing on psychological depth and structured plotlines, offering a different but equally engaging cinematic experience.

Watch our collections on Movieitaly+
Read more articles over here!